Probably Not the Best Analogy

By Evan Falchuk

President Obama held a town hall meeting today, which seems to have gone well.

Except he decided to use an analogy to dispute the idea that a government-run health insurer would drive private insurers out of business:

“As long as they have a good product and the government plan has to sustain itself through premiums and other non-tax revenue, private insurers should be able to compete with the government plan,” Obama said.  “They do it all the time,” he said.  “UPS and Fedex are doing just fine. . . . it’s the Post Office that’s always having problems.”

This is probably not the best analogy.

The US Postal Service has a monopoly on first-class mail, and is staffed pretty much completely by government workers.  As good as these workers are, the idea of the Post Office evokes images of waiting on line, and the rising cost of stamps.

And as for the villainous health insurers, are they now UPS and Fedex?

It is all very hard to follow.  It’s no wonder even people paying close attention to this issue are left wondering what these plans are all about.

  • "Medicine is learned by the bedside and not in the class room. Let not your conception of manifestations of disease come from work heard in the lecture room or read from the book: see and then research, compare and control. But see first."
    - Sir William Osler, MD
    The Father of Modern Medicine
  • Connect



    BestDoctors.com


    On Twitter


    On Facebook


    Via RSS


    On YouTube


    Subscribe via Email

  • Benefits Package

    BenefitsPackageButton

    Join the best in employer health-benefits blogging!

  • Follow Us on YouTube:

  • Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

  • Categories

  • Archives